1.2.05
Two perspectives on Iraq from RAND
18:27 | Posted by
liminal |
Edit Post
Another Perspective: Brian Michael Jenkins deflates the idea that battling terrorists in Iraq averts battling them in America
RAND | Newsroom | Commentary | Iraq: Not Terrorist Central: "Brian Michael Jenkins deflates the idea that battling terrorists in Iraq averts battling them in America
By fighting terrorists in Iraq, does America reduce the likelihood it will have to fight them in the United States? It is an appealing idea to a nation that continues to worry about another 9/11, but on careful analysis the argument does not stand up.
Taking the fight to terrorists abroad — as America did by invading Afghanistan and by continuing efforts against terrorists worldwide — makes sense. But Iraq is a separate and special case, because many of the combatants killed or captured by American and allied forces in Iraq are insurgents created by opposition to the U.S. invasion itself. They have little to do with the jihadists that the United States has been actively hunting since 9/11, although some have been converted to al-Qaida's ideology since joining the resistance.
Iraq is not a geographic front line through which terrorists must pass physically to reach American shores. We are not heading them off at the pass. The jihadists and their recruiting reservoirs are dispersed throughout the populations of Asia, the Middle East, North Africa, Europe, and to a lesser degree North America. They are inspired by al-Qaida's ideology, but they are also fired up about local issues.
Fighting in Iraq is not so distracting to the jihadist enterprise that it is unable to prepare and carry out terrorist attacks elsewhere. Al-Qaida was never a highly centralized operation. Under intense pressure for the past 39 months, it has further decentralized. Local jihadist operatives are doing more on their own. Since 9/11, jihadists have carried out major terrorist attacks from Bali to Madrid, on an average of once every two months, not counting incidents in Russia or Iraq. The pace of terrorist operations has not slowed a bit since the invasion of Iraq.
True, some of the foreign jihadists who showed up to fight in Iraq might have been candidates for operations at home had there been no war. But their numbers do not appear to be great, and most are from countries adjacent to Iraq.
Taken literally, the argument that battling terrorists in Iraq averts battling them in America and elsewhere assumes there is roughly a fixed number of terrorists in the world. Following this logic, when U.S. officials say that three-quarters of al-Qaida's leaders have been killed or captured, or when they talk about the total number of terrorists detained worldwide, we could simply subtract this number from the ranks of those who are plotting to attack the United States and elsewhere. Unfortunately, this is not the case.
Counting terrorists is slippery business. The jihadist population itself is dynamic. Recruiting has continued successfully since 9/11 — some analysts believe it has increased as a consequence of the terrorist attacks. And opinion polls among Muslims suggest that growing antipathy toward the United States is expanding the jihadists' recruiting reservoir.
At the same time, terrorist losses are continuous. In addition to those killed and captured, some of those who went through the training camps claim to have decided right away that al-Qaida's brand of jihad was not for them. Others, no doubt, have dropped out in the years since they attended training.
Jihadists also vary in their level of commitment. Some are willing to serve as martyrs, while others are willing only to provide passive support, prompting terrorist leaders to complain of substandard zeal.
That leaves us with a terrorist population that is simultaneously expanding and eroding, and whose individual members are constantly recalibrating their level of commitment.
The “fighting them there, not here” school of thought makes sense if one conflates the threat posed by terrorists like Osama bin Laden with that of hostile tyrants with nuclear ambitions like Saddam Hussein. Although claims of a prior relationship between al-Qaida and Hussein have been largely abandoned, the argument assumes inevitable (if not demonstrable) links.
This is the core belief underlying the “global war on terror,” which views the proliferation of weapons of mass destruction and escalating terrorism as a single threat. It presumes that proliferating states — reluctant to use nuclear or other unconventional weapons themselves and risk retaliation — will hand the weapons over to terrorists, who are likely to use them against U.S. targets.
On his recent visit to Baghdad, British Prime Minister Tony Blair offered a more nuanced interpretation of the connection between the fighting in Iraq and the fight against terrorism. “If Iraq becomes a stable, democratic country able to defeat terrorism here [in Iraq] — which is the same kind of terrorism that we face the world over — if we can defeat it here, we deal it a blow worldwide,” Blair said. Putting aside the crucial “if” in the prime minister's statement — and forgetting for the moment that the current terrorism in Iraq is a product of the invasion itself — this argument sees terrorism in Iraq and worldwide as a single phenomenon that nonetheless can be dealt a blow in Iraq.
The most ambitious and optimistic proponents of the fighting-them-there thesis would reach further, arguing that only by profoundly altering the Middle East's political situation from failed states and corrupt tyrants to the stable, democratic allies envisioned by Prime Minister Blair can the United States ever hope to defeat terrorism. According to this line of thinking, political change brought about by armed might in Iraq will spread from Baghdad to Damascus, Tehran, Riyadh, Cairo and beyond.
Ironically, this is exactly the way the jihadists see the non-Muslim world, making no distinctions between U.S., Israeli, Indian, Serbian and Russian policies. And they similarly call for expansion of the jihad, urging their followers to fight now instead of waiting for the infidels to invade the jihadists' countries.
Some might even say, “Fighting the infidels in Iraq means not fighting them here.”
RAND | Newsroom | Commentary | Iraq: Not Terrorist Central: "Brian Michael Jenkins deflates the idea that battling terrorists in Iraq averts battling them in America
Blog Archive
-
▼
2005
(509)
-
▼
February
(127)
- Be happy, rest, savor the victory...
- Commentary on the Lebanese situation
- The entire Lebanese government resigns, now Lahoud...
- VICTORY #1: Prime Minister Omar Karameh Steps Down
- Thousands rally in Beirut, Pre-empting the protest...
- Syria Did It
- If you get the chance...
- Max Ehrmann sums it up in Desiderata
- Who is your daddy, and what does he do?
- The Right Wing Echo Chamber on Video
- If William Faulkner were writing on the Bush White...
- Feeling Iraq'd?
- Iraqi women live in fear, Amnesty says
- Egypt announces democratic reform: Nawal Saadawi f...
- No votes in Nineveh: We are the new Kurds, a crush...
- Marine escapes charges over Fallujah shooting beca...
- You can't be patriotic if you're gay, it's against...
- Nuclear Security: Georgey's gotta prop Putin up
- This just in: Jaafari chosen as Iraq's next Prime...
- Resume: GWBoosh
- Kulluna lil-watan, lil'ula lil-'alam...
- Nietzsche and Ahmed
- Amen Bob, amen...
- Hunter S. Thompson rest in peace
- 50 Questions for Alberto Gonzales
- Slavoj Zizek: The empty wheelbarrow
- Nick Kilroy rest in peace
- I got pepper in my eye. Don't ask how...So, I hav...
- Classic - Rainbow TV
- Nobel Peace Prize Winner: Attacking Iran would br...
- Chronicles of the Teflon President: The Secret Ta...
- Government Accountability Office Warns Federal Age...
- The White House has ties to gay prostitution
- Frontline causes controversy...again.
- Most Americans Don't Know..
- U.S. Soldiers Taking Ecstasy
- Pentagon Prepares To Build $130bn Robot Army
- Jon Stewart's Daily Show on Bloggers 02/16/05
- Friedman is lying about meeting Hariri in the 70s:...
- DNI = Subservient Yes Man That Turns Blind Eye to ...
- No title
- Lebanese Blogger Forum
- dEsIGn70s
- Laura Rozen provides an interesting linkhere that ...
- ((((((((SHOCK)))))))))))
- Lebanese Blogs
- Attending to the Fly of the Emperor
- Un Regard Moderne - Edition du mardi 15 fevrier 2005
- US Accused of Plan to Muzzle al-Jazeera Through Pr...
- Bene Diction Blogs On: Accountability: Church Recr...
- Pop-up Windows?
- The End of Blogging? Google Pulls The Plug
- Military Mission
- Comments
- Israeli spies, Syrian obsession and a peace that h...
- The killing of 'Mr Lebanon': Rafik Hariri assassin...
- What did I tell you about the Security Council?
- Reactions from Lebanon after Hariri's Assassination
- Incompetence in the Wild West Why Allawi, the CPA...
- Ereli Impressed...
- Teez'oh Sol'iff l'oh
- Lebanon Bomb
- DoS/International Information Programs: Foreign Co...
- Paranoia Grips US
- Chomsky: Budget attacks America's majority
- Weakness of attitude becomes weakness of character...
- Discussions and Posts about the Creepy church recr...
- Juan Cole gives an election roundup that's worth c...
- The London Independent reveals, Training of Iraq'...
- 5,500 US Troops flee the war in Iraq
- EFFICIENT VERSION: Holy S**t! It's fascist picture...
- l e b a n e s e s u n r i s e
- See, Speak, Hear No Evil
- LOOK, I'M REALLY FRUSTRATED RIGHT NOW. I CANNOT M...
- River blogs about elections, the stories, the time...
- The Incredible Joe Wilson Speaks Out at the Daily Kos
- No War on Iran!
- Carnival, Mardi Gras, or Iraq?
- Anger is an energy -P.I.
- Grrrr... this makes me so angry. You have no clue...
- Via Marie at the kos: Pentagon to broadcast to mil...
- CROOKS AND LIARS...that's only the tip of it.
- I'm a sucker for satire.
- CBFTW: This blog is no longer a blog written by a ...
- Masters of Blog
- I love Senator Barbara Boxer.
- PMBC Men's Night Out January 28, 2005: some more m...
- Gannon the fake reporter for a fake news organisat...
- sometimes we wonder why air is so indifferent to l...
- dowd on madame hawk's scripted questions
- Please Listen to Zeyad
- .tiff screenshots of the Church Recruitment Incide...
- Mark of JSF enlightens me about a campaign of conf...
- An Iraqi nationalist party is needed
- In an attempt to clear the mental palette, I retur...
- Holy S**t! It's fascist picture story time!!
- The soft and the pliable will defeat the hard and ...
- Avi Shlaim writes Why Zionism today is the real en...
- Become a conscientious objector
- File on 4: BBC tells how $9 billion was stolen fr...
-
▼
February
(127)
Iraqi Culture
Sites
- Korea Life Blog
- Toothing
- Academic Secret
- African Food Blog
- Genius Duck
- Blogopoly
- Second String Swap
- Work at Home News
- Bashhh
- Just Another Opinion Blog
- Hairstyles and Nails
- Chiefly Musing Home Tips
- Health Talk and You
- Awryt
- Zacquisha
- Hairstyles and Nails
- Health Talk and You
- link
- Saints Car Club
- Moon Rider
- Super Pong
- Jeffrey Scott Band
- Fusion Recipes
- Oregon Lawyers
- Rent Empress
- Jake Gyllenhaal Fan Club
- Hurdler Page
- link
- Johnny Bravo Site
- link
- Survey Land
- Internet Data
- link
- Film Acting
- Golden Girls Quotes
- link
- Soda Traders
- The Chess Haven
- Integrity Library
- A&F Models
- Dancer's Domain
- Myanmar Institute of Technology
- link
- Pilgrim's Products
- Redhead Hair Site
- Olympics Page
0 comments:
Post a Comment